Manchester City's problem with Erling Haaland looks a lot like the one Bayern Munich has worn down its own squad over, first with Robert Lewandowski and now with Harry Kane. That's the view of former City and England defender Danny Mills, who spoke to BOYLE Sports about the trouble of finding a quality backup for a striker who's already the undisputed first choice. On the surface, it sounds like a nice problem to have. Clubs would generally rather have one elite striker than none. But Mills's comparison points at something less comfortable: when your first-choice forward is good enough to dominate, the players who could replace him often stop being interested in your project.
Mills earned 19 England caps and also played for Leeds United and Middlesbrough during his career, so he's seen the position from several angles. That matters here. A player who's been on different sides of that equation understands the psychology of the role better than a pundit who only watched from the stands. (and this is the part most people overlook) the mindset of a backup striker is shaped by the same instincts that made him a striker in the first place. Mills isn't guessing about the bench.
A catch-22 for squad builders
Mills pointed to City winning the league largely without Sergio Agüero as proof the club found a workable route. Bringing in an out-and-out center-forward while Haaland is in place, though, is a different matter. "It's very, very difficult to bring in an out-and-out center-forward when you've got Erling Haaland in place because you have to bring in someone that is happy to sit on the bench," he said. "There aren't too many top strikers that are gonna come in and be happy knowing that they're gonna be second choice."
The first half of that argument is easy to accept. Clubs have won without a dominant number nine before, and City's own history with Agüero is the evidence Mills leans on. The second half is where it gets tricky. Squad planning assumes you can buy depth, but depth at this level is a specific product: a striker good enough to start elsewhere and willing to wait his turn. That combination is rarer than the transfer market's sheer size suggests.
He called it a catch-22. The players good enough to start for most clubs rarely want to wait behind an established star, and Bayern's recent history shows it. "Who would go to Bayern Munich behind Kane and think they're going to play?" Mills asked. Strikers that good are scarce, and that scarcity is the whole problem.
Here's the thing: the bench isn't just a seat. It's a signal about minutes, status and future value. A striker who signs as a backup is effectively betting that an injury or a change in coaching will open a path, and that's a bet most ambitious forwards won't make willingly. I'd argue this is more significant than it looks, because it means clubs can't simply solve the problem with money. A big enough contract might buy a player, but it doesn't guarantee he'll stay content watching from the touchline.
Keeping Haaland fit matters most
Mills called Haaland a fantastic talent and said the priority is keeping him fit. Teams have always built around their best forwards, he argued, pointing to Messi and Ronaldo. He also raised Chelsea without Didier Drogba in the big moments. Those players aren't irreplaceable, he said, but replacing them like for like is very hard.
That's a more useful framing than it might sound at first. If you're a supporter trying to judge whether your club is doing enough, this is the lens to use. Depth is the insurance policy, but availability is the real product. A star who stays on the pitch makes the backup question far less urgent than any amount of transfer window speculation.
The Chelsea example cuts both ways, and that's worth sitting with. Losing a key forward in the big moments exposes a squad, but it also shows that clubs have historically survived those absences. The problem isn't that no one can fill the gap. The problem is that filling it like for like, with a player of the same quality and the same appetite for the spotlight, is a much taller order.
Here's the thing: Bayern supporters have already lived this. Finding a striker who can push Kane or Lewandowski is hard enough, and convincing that player to accept a backup role is a separate challenge entirely. That's why rumors linking strikers to backup roles at big clubs usually meet skepticism. For City, the practical question is whether they can keep Haaland fit enough that the backup question stays theoretical.
What this means for City and beyond
The lesson here is about sequencing. Clubs that build around one dominant forward often assume the second striker is a simple purchase they can make later. Mills's argument suggests that assumption deserves a second look, because the pool of players willing to accept the role is much smaller than the pool of players who are good enough for it. If you're working in recruitment, scouting or writing about transfers, treat any reported interest in a backup striker as a question about the player's ambitions, not just the club's budget.
And yet the pattern keeps repeating. Bayern moved from Lewandowski to Kane, and each handover raised the same question about who would accept waiting. That's the trap Mills is describing. A club that succeeds with an elite striker can end up with a squad that has no clear answer once that striker is unavailable, and the cost of that gap only becomes visible during injury spells or long runs of fixtures.
I'm not going to predict how City's next moves will play out, and the facts in this interview don't support a firm forecast anyway. Mills offers a diagnosis, not a plan. What I'd watch is whether the club treats Haaland's fitness as the primary defense, as Mills suggests, or whether it starts quietly testing the market for a striker who'd accept second billing. Either approach tells you something about how seriously the club takes the problem.